Miami police Chief John Timoney must be mighty proud of the social
order he maintained during the Free Trade Area of the Americas summit a
couple of weeks ago in Miami - sort of the way Saddam Hussein was proud
of quieting dissension in his country.
Timoney has a well-deserved reputation for using paramilitary
tactics to turn any city where large protests are planned into a place
where the Constitution has taken a holiday. During the FTAA meeting on
Nov. 20, Timoney dispatched 2,500 police officers in full riot gear
against a crowd estimated at 8,000 people, mostly union members and
retirees.
The result was a show of force that would have made a Latin American dictator blush.
Slavish public officials such as Miami Mayor Manny Diaz touted
Timoney's handiwork as "a model for homeland defense," and the Miami
Police Department has responded to complaints by saying that officers
demonstrated "a tremendous amount of restraint."
But this is hardly the way eyewitnesses described it. The scene
was a "massive police state," according to the president of the United
Steelworkers of America, who has demanded a congressional investigation.
Congress gave Miami $8.5-million for security during the FTAA meetings -
funds slipped inside the $87-billion measure for Iraq. The steelworkers
called it money for "homeland repression."
The National Lawyers Guild, a liberal legal organization, said
the day was punctuated by "indiscriminate, excessive force against
hundreds of nonviolent protesters with weapons including pepper spray,
tear gas, and concussion grenades and rubber bullets."
Observers said the provocation for officers to shoot rubber
bullets and paint balls filled with pepper spray at the predominantly
peaceable crowd was often one person lobbing an orange in the direction
of police or lighting a trash can on fire.
Nikki Hartman, a 28-year-old Pinellas County resident, was shot
three times with rubber bullets - once, she said, when a police officer
fired point-blank at her behind after she stooped to pick up a bandanna
she'd dropped. The officer had kicked it her way before shooting her.
She was later shot in the back while retreating from police lines. Her
friend Robert Davis was shot seven times while trying to help Hartman to
her feet.
In addition to such shootings, police abandoned any legitimate
basis for searching and arresting people. Miles Swanson, 25, a legal
observer for the lawyers guild, was punched numerous times while being
taken in by officers for pointing out undercover police dressed up as
protesters. Eight of 60 guild observers were arrested that day; they
wore distinctive green hats and were apparently targeted. When Swanson
was grabbed off the street by three Broward County sheriff's deputies -
two of whom were in ski masks - he said they told him "this is what you
get when you f-- with us." Then, Swanson said, the deputies drove him
around while looking for another legal observer to arrest. He ultimately
pleaded no contest to one charge of obstructing justice so he could return to law school in Washington, D.C.
Celeste Fraser Delgado, a 36-year-old reporter for the Miami New
Times, was interviewing protesters when she was arrested. According to
an Associated Press report of her ordeal, she overheard police arguing
about what to charge her with. The two misdemeanors - failure to obey a
legal command and resisting arrest without violence - were dropped the next day.
The police seemed especially sensitive to having their actions
photographed or taped. Sean Lidberg, who was stringing for a Minnesota
paper, said his group of friends was aggressively detained and searched
by police because one of them had picked up and put down a coconut found
on the ground.
"We're from Minnesota and never saw coconuts growing wild," said
the 20-year-old Lidberg. When he tried to take video of the police
searching through his backpack, Lidberg said, "they shoved the camera
down and wouldn't let me document anything said or done." Police
proceeded to take most of what he had in his backpack, which included
two gas masks. He doesn't expect to see his stuff again.
When contacted for comment, the Miami police first asked for case
numbers. When those were provided, the public information officer said
he didn't have time to comment on the incidents and hung up when his
name was requested.
Ever since the melee at the 1999 World Trade Organization meeting
in Seattle, where demonstrators blocked streets and vandalized stores,
conference planners and public officials have adopted a no-holds-barred
approach to potential large-scale protests. And Timoney is their man.
Militant protesters, "punks" as he calls them, are anathema to Timoney.
Shutting them down with Pinkerton prowess is his specialty. Rights,
schmights.
Anyone who cares about civil liberties might remember Timoney as
the police commissioner of Philadelphia during the 2000 Republican
convention - an event marked by police making pre-emptive arrests on
baseless charges and smashing heads. This led to lucrative private
consulting offers for Timoney and then, this year, to the top-cop spot
in Miami.
His antiprotester philosophy is a fitting sign of the times and
intersects nicely with the new FBI protocols established by Attorney
General John Ashcroft. Ashcroft recently junked FBI guidelines that
prevented agents from monitoring groups without evidence of criminal
wrongdoing, saying it was vital for antiterrorism operations. But in a
J. Edgar Hoover redux, it turns out that this flexibility is being used
to spy on and collect intelligence on antiwar protesters.
When men like Timoney and Ashcroft are on the A-list of the
nation's law enforcers, free speech doesn't stand a chance. It is open
season on dissent. A vignette reported by the Miami Herald says it all:
During the FTAA action, Timoney came upon a protester who was pinned
against a car being arrested; without knowing anything about the
circumstances, he pointed a finger at the demonstrator's face and said,
"You're bad. F-- you!" People exercising their First Amendment rights
are now considered the enemy.
FAIR USE NOTICE: This page contains copyrighted
material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the
copyright owner. NoNonsense English offers this material
non-commercially for research and educational purposes. I believe this
constitutes a fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for
in 17 U.S.C ยง 107. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this
site for purposes of your own that go beyond fair use, you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner, i.e. the media service or newspaper
which first published the article online and which is indicated at the
top of the article unless otherwise specified. |