The Free Trade Area of the Americas talks have been over for two
weeks now, and most of the national media covering the events wrapped it
up neatly on Thursday, November 20, the day the meetings ended. Their
happy news: The talks were a success and the protests were peaceful
except for a few pesky radicals dealt with by vigilant police.
But even as most media were gearing up for All-Jacko-All-the-Time
coverage, stories began emerging about police abuses during the talks
-- people beaten without provocation, people arrested for no reason,
their belongings taken and trashed. Last Tuesday the United Steelworkers
of America and the Alliance for Retired Americans called for a
congressional investigation into police tactics during an AFL-CIO-led
press conference at which Miami's police chief, John Timoney, was
accused of breaking an agreement to allow buses carrying retired union
members into a rally. On Wednesday a coalition of activists held a press
conference denouncing the actions of police during the FTAA summit. The
stories of police violence against protesters that had been piling up
on activist Websites and in chat rooms began leaching into the mainstream media.
One of the more inflammatory vignettes described a police attack
on an ad hoc medical clinic where injured protesters were being treated.
Details of the incident surfaced late in the afternoon of November 20,
when it was described on protest Websites such as resist.ca and
alternative news sites including www.ftaaimc.org and indymedia.org. The
first reports came in minute-by-minute posts written by laptop-laden
protesters, like this one from www.ftaaimc.org: "11-20-2003 16:54
Wellness Center -- Cops using tear gas indiscriminately, moving close to
the wellness center at 5th and N Miami. Outside decontamination spaces
at wellness center had to be shut down because tear gas is lingering."
The center, set up in a rented storefront space at 532 N. Miami
Ave. by teams of off-duty emergency medical technicians, physicians, and
"street medics" (volunteers carrying first-aid kits and water), was a
place for protesters to wash off pepper spray and receive treatment for
basic injuries. Those with serious injuries would be stabilized and sent
to a hospital. (These types of protest-specific clinics began springing
up after medical collectives organized in the wake of Seattle's 1999
violent antiglobalization protests.)
The crowd inside the North Miami Avenue clinic and out on the
sidewalk was composed of protesters and medics -- who generally looked
like protesters but wore red or black crosses pinned to their jackets
and hats. Glass double doors and two bay windows
fronted the Wellness Center. A sign with foot-high letters reading
"Wellness Center" was prominently displayed in one of the windows.
Travis Rabbit, a street medic in town from Brooklyn for the
protests, was on the sidewalk outside the center between 4:00 and 5:00
p.m. on Thursday, about the same time riot police began pursuing
protesters from Bayfront Park, pushing north and west. Stragglers from
the escalating confrontations were turning up at the center, and Rabbit
was washing pepper spray off those who needed it. "A line of police
turned the corner from, I think it was Fourth Street, onto North Miami
Avenue," he recounts. "They came up the street toward us, and there was a
rush for the door. The people inside couldn't let everyone hide in
there -- they were treating patients. Plus we didn't want people in
there who'd been sprayed but not cleaned."
EMT Liz Highleyman, a member of the Bay Area Radical Health
Collective in San Francisco, was also on the sidewalk. "The staff tried
to close the doors as the police got to the center," she says, "but they
couldn't get them closed because of the people trying to get in. Then a
police officer stuck his hand in there and sprayed pepper spray all
over the inside of the Wellness Center."
Rabbit was stuck in the melee outside the door. "The police sort
of pinned a bunch of us against the walls and doors outside the Wellness
Center," he says. "Right before the doors closed, one of the officers
stuck a can of pepper spray in and sprayed. Then they started spraying
all of us who were outside, and they used batons on those of us in
front. I tried to get away and was struck a number of times on my back,
my knees, and my stomach. They kept telling us to move on but they
wouldn't let us move. I crawled out of the crowd, and I couldn't see."
Eowyn A. Rieke, a physician from Boston and a member of the
Boston Area Liberation Medics Squad, was inside the clinic Thursday
afternoon. Rieke and about eight other staffers were assessing injuries
in a waiting area and treating patients in makeshift rooms created by
ceiling-hung tarps. In all there were about 30 patients inside when the
cops showed up, Rieke says.
"There was a big rush of people," she recalls, "and we were
working really hard. All of a sudden people started yelling, and there
was a rush through the door. We saw the police come into view through
the door, and right when it was almost closed, one of the police in riot
gear stuck his hand through the door." The policeman was wearing brown
riot gear, Rieke says; Miami-Dade County Police wore brown gear during
the protests. "The place just filled up with pepper spray."
Ron Rosen, a doctor of Oriental medicine from Colorado, was even
closer to the door. "I was outside treating two people who seemed to
have internal injuries," he reports. "We were about to get one of them
to the hospital when the police line came up the street. I was trying to
get the patient into the clinic when I was hit in the shoulder with a
rubber bullet." Rosen says he was wearing a stethoscope around his neck
and a vest with the word "Medic" in four-inch yellow letters when he was
shot. "I got the guy inside and was trying to get back out to help my
other patient when the woman doing door security at the Wellness Center
tried to close the door. I still remember the look of absolute rage on
the policeman's face when he sprayed her in the face with his pepper
spray."
All the medics say there were no protest activities emanating
from the clinic, and that while they didn't interrogate those who
arrived for treatment, neither did they allow the center to become a
refuge for protesters hiding from police. Says Rieke: "We work very hard
to maintain neutrality for the specific reason that we won't be
targeted by police and we can continue to treat people."
The story is "absurd on its face," says Miami Police Department
spokesman Delrish Moss. "We have no reports of anything happening at the
Wellness Center. And in terms of the police going around doing things
like that, it's just ridiculous to think that they'd waste their time
that way."
Miami-Dade Police spokesman Det. Robert Williams says that
pepper-spraying medical facilities "is not something we would do."
Williams says there is no record of any such incident. "Just like any
agency, we have our own watchdog group, our internal-affairs bureau. If
these people are alleging that this happened they should make a
complaint through official channels."
FAIR USE NOTICE: This page contains copyrighted
material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the
copyright owner. NoNonsense English offers this material
non-commercially for research and educational purposes. I believe this
constitutes a fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for
in 17 U.S.C ยง 107. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this
site for purposes of your own that go beyond fair use, you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner, i.e. the media service or newspaper
which first published the article online and which is indicated at the
top of the article unless otherwise specified. |