Miami,
Florida - the police meet me at the airport. I've just flown in to
conduct workshops at the Free Trade of the Americas meetings. But to get
into downtown Miami anywhere close to the perimeter requires a special
permit. The cost: $80 U.S. and a background check
conducted by state and federal officials. The situation reminds me of
the Mastercard commercials, but with a twist. Downtown travel pass in
Miami? $80. Freedom to speak your mind? Priceless.
Downtown
Miami on November 18 is empty. Businesses are closed and have been for
nearly a week. The Miami Herald publishes a telling editorial cartoon
that day: a map of the Americas on one side, labelled "Free trade," and
alongside that a map of downtown Miami with the words "No trade"
scrawled across the buildings.
Instead
of the general bustle one typically sees in this diverse city, there
are only uniformly dressed paramilitary personnel from 45 different
police departments - everywhere. The enormous, heavily armed police and
riot squad presence have been recruited to secure the downtown zone.
Juan,
an émigré from Cuba and a 20-year veteran policeman, meets and vets me
at the airport. He tells me, "These protestors," gesturing toward
mysterious places, "are killers - cop killers." In Seattle, he says,
"they killed a cop, and also in Cancun." I know this to be blatantly
untrue, but attempts to politely correct him won't be heard. In fact,
over the next few days I often hear this refrain of
protestors-equals-cop-killers. A mindset has been established, and the
facts are not necessary.
Juan
gestures again. "They piss in balloons and throw them at police. They
come here armed and dangerous. But here in Miami they've met their match,"
he says proudly. "If they try and reach you" (believing I'm onside with
him) - he gestures at me with his finger as if it were a dagger - "we
will cut them off even before they get close to you." His finger folds
like it was sliced off at the knuckle.
The irony of my position inside the perimeter next to Juan makes me smile.
Also
boarding the bus are a half- dozen members of Canada's Department of
Foreign Affairs, Industry & Trade (DFAIT), and the six-pack of suits
are thrilled with the macho police attention. Settling into the luxury
bus, they exchange info on Miami's fine golf courses
and which private schools they attended, and remark that the different
vistas en route to downtown Miami are reminiscent of Nicaragua or El
Salvador. They joke disparagingly that Jack Layton will attend their
briefing sessions. "He doesn't know the issues at all," one recent
graduate from an MBA program sneers.
There's
no evidence that this city is preparing to assist the thousands of
workers, retirees, environmentalists, faith group members and youth who
have publicly announced for weeks their plans to come to Florida to
peacefully register their opposition to more negotiations for a trade deal they do not
want. In fact, a city ordinance was passed a few weeks before the FTAA
ministerial was to begin making it illegal for more than eight persons
to gather on the streets.
The
training these 8,000 police have undergone has portrayed citizens as
thugs. Their deployment cost $8.5 million, allocated from a U.S. federal
government appropriation, a line item within the $87 billion requested
and granted for the rebuilding of Iraq.
How
is the money spent? Picture this. Thursday is the big day for speeches
and a legally permitted march. Unions, with the approval of the
authorities, have rented the amphitheatre at Bayshore Park as the
meeting point for thousands of protestors. Tens of thousands come
prepared to hear speeches by labour leaders, environmentalists and
community activists and then participate in a legally sanctioned,
peaceful 2-mile march to register their concerns.
Access
is controlled. Thousands of riot police surround the city blocks
adjacent to the park. Intersections are shut down, and only a string of
three or four people can pass at any one time. One hundred eighty-seven
buses carrying workers from around the state not permitted into the
city, and others carrying retirees, are stopped 10 blocks from the
venue, contrary to the negotiated agreement with the police. Hundreds of
elders are forced to walk to the venue in the sun and have to run a
gauntlet of riot police to get to the amphitheatre and shade.
After
the peaceful and subdued march, a woman lawyer dressed in a skirt and
high heels holds up a sign that reads "Fear totalitarianism" in front of
a squad of 500 armed riot police.
A
crowd of fewer than 100 people is with her. Police don't demand their
dispersal; rather, they shoot rubber bullets into the crowd from near
point blank range. The woman lawyer lowers her sign to protect her head.
The police aim and shoot through the sign, hitting her in the head.
A
small band of citizens march to the courthouse to protest these
intimidation tactics and the wrongful arrest of more than 250 people.
Hundreds of police and squad cars surround this small group, which
includes students at Harvard studying trade agreements and social
movements and with whom we have spent time. Notice to disperse is given.
The crowd raise their hands in the air, indicating they have no rocks
or weapons, and walk backwards away from the scene loudly chanting, "We
are dispersing."
Armed
snipers drop to one knee and begin shooting into the crowd with rubber
bullets at citizens who are walking backwards. My friend is hit in the
leg; others take repeated hits of rubber bullets and pepper balls.
Surrounded,
their attempts to disperse are prevented. More than 50 people are
arrested and charged with unlawful assembly, resisting arrest or
assault. One trooper remarks, "You may beat the charge, but you can't
beat the ride."
Protestors
are now being released or are calling from jail with reports of
excessive brutality, sexual assaults and torture. People are denied
access to attorneys, visitation rights and essential medication and
medical attention. Over 100 protestors are treated for injuries, and 12
are hospitalized.
Military
tanks patrol the streets after dark on Thursday night. Canada's trade
minister, Pierre Pettigrew, remarks that he was unfazed by the citizens
he does not agree with because he couldn't see or hear them from inside
the heavily fortified Intercontinental Hotel, where the talks were
taking place. "We don't sense their presence at all," Mr. Pettigrew said
of those on the street.
Back
to the Mastercard commercial. Politicians' disconnect from reality?
$8.5 million. Civil liberties? Priceless.
Karl Flecker is education coordinator at the Ottawa-based Polaris Institute.
FAIR USE NOTICE: This page contains copyrighted
material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the
copyright owner. NoNonsense English offers this material
non-commercially for research and educational purposes. I believe this
constitutes a fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for
in 17 U.S.C § 107. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this
site for purposes of your own that go beyond fair use, you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner, i.e. the media service or newspaper
which first published the article online and which is indicated at the
top of the article unless otherwise specified. |